Vol. 40 No. 1 (2026): AHS 150 years
Articles

Efficacy of Aloe and Opuntia based composts on growth and phytochemical properties of Salvia officinalis and Rosmarinus officinalis

pdf
  • D. Prisa,
  • A. Jamal
D. Prisa
CREA Research Centre for Vegetable and Ornamental Crops, Council for Agricultural Research and Economics, Via dei Fiori, 8, 51017 Pescia (PT), Italy.
A. Jamal
Department of Soil and Environmental Sciences, Faculty of Crop Production Sciences, The University of Agriculture, 25130 Peshawar, Pakistan.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.36253/ahsc-18599
Categories

Published 2026-04-07

Keywords

  • Biostimulants,
  • essential oil composition,
  • organic cultivation,
  • plant secondary metabolites,
  • sustainable agriculture

How to Cite

prisa, domenico, & Jamal, A. (2026). Efficacy of Aloe and Opuntia based composts on growth and phytochemical properties of Salvia officinalis and Rosmarinus officinalis. Advances in Horticultural Science, 40(1), 29–46. https://doi.org/10.36253/ahsc-18599

Copyright (c) 2026 domenico prisa, Aftab Jamal

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Crossref
Scopus
Google Scholar
Europe PMC

Abstract

The sustainable cultivation of medicinal and aromatic plants requires alternative substrates that reduce dependence on peat and synthetic fertilisers, while promoting acceptable plant growth and adequate phytochemical quality. This study evaluated the effects of five compost treatments on Salvia officinalis and Rosmarinus officinalis grown in greenhouses at CREA (Pescia, Italy). The treatments examined in this study include use of a peat-based control, commercial compost, monospecific composts derived from Aloe arborescens, Aloe barbadensis and Opuntia ficus-indica, plus a mixed Aloe-Opuntia compost. Growth parameters, photosynthetic performance, chlorophyll content, water and resource use efficiency, microbial biomass and secondary metabolites (phenols, flavonoids, essential oils) for both species were evaluated. For both species tested, the peat-based control supported consistently the best vegetative growth, highest phytochemical levels and was confirmed to be the best for physical support in greenhouse conditions. The mixed Aloe-Opuntia compost functioned similarly to the peat-based control, yet it showed a 5-8% reduction in vegetative growth, however, it still had a higher physiological/metabolic level than other compost based treatments. The results indicate that it is possible to use composts containing a combination of materials with complementary structural and biochemical properties to help overcome some of the limitations of single-species composts. On the other hand, composts made from Aloe vera alone exhibited the weakest agronomic and physiological performances likely due to having a higher electrical conductivity, high rapid decomposition rates, and having a poorly developed substrate structure even though it had a high total nutrient content. There was no difference in the safety of all composts; they caused no negative effects on plant survival, pest infestation, or disease occurrence. Such promising results were recorded particularly for mixed composts, but due to the fact that this was a greenhouse trial, there is a need for further replication to confirm findings. In conclusion, mixed plant composts could be a more sustainable solution, environmentally friendly for producing aromatic plants, and will reduce the reliance on the limited supply of peat.

pdf

References

  1. AGUILAR-PAREDES A., VALDÉS G., ARANEDA N., VALDEBENITO E., HANSEN F., NUTI M., 2023 - Microbial community in the composting process and its positive impact on the soil biota in sustainable agriculture. - Agronomy, 13(2): 542.
  2. AHMAD N., JAN S.A., SAJJAD W., FAISAL S., GAO B.-X., 2018 - In vitro antimicrobial activity of Aloe vera L. extracts against pathogenic bacteria and fungi. - Mycopath, 14(2): 87-92.
  3. AHMED U., JAMAL A., IQBAL W., DURRISHAHWAR, QAYYUM U., SAEED M. F., ALI A., RONGA D., DEWIR Y. H., ČERNÝ J., 2025 - Integrated management of nitrogen and spent mushroom compost for improved wheat yield and soil fertility. - J. Soil Sci. Plant Nutr., 25: 3354-3371.
  4. ALBAYRAK S., 2013 - The volatile compounds and bioactivity of Achillea sieheana Stapf. (Asteraceae). - Iranian J. Pharm. Res., 12(1): 37-45.
  5. ANGIONI A., BARRA A., CERETI E., BARILE D., COÏSSON J. D., ARLORIO M., DESSI S., CORONEO V., CABRAS P., 2004 - Chemical composition, plant genetic differences, antimicrobial and antifungal activity investigation of the essential oil of Rosmarinus officinalis L. - J. Agric. Food Chem., 52(11): 3530-3535.
  6. ARSENE M. M., VIKTOROVNA P. I., SERGEI G. V., HAJJAR F., VYACHESLAVOVNA Y. N., VLADIMIROVNA Z. A., ALEKSANDROVNA V. E., NIKOLAYEVICH S. A., SACHIVKINA N., 2022 - Phytochemical analysis, antibacterial and antibiofilm activities of Aloe vera aqueous extract against selected resistant Gram-negative bacteria involved in urinary tract infections. - Fermentation, 8(11): 626.
  7. ATIYEH R., SUBLER S., EDWARDS C., BACHMAN G., METZGER J., SHUSTER W., 2000 - Effects of vermicomposts and composts on plant growth in horticultural container media and soil. - Pedobiologia, 44(5-6): 579-590.
  8. ATZORI G., PANE C., ZACCARDELLI M., CACINI S., MASSA D., 2021 - The role of peat-free organic substrates in the sustainable management of soilless cultivations. - Agronomy, 11: 1236.
  9. AUTERI N., SAIANO F., SCALENGHE R., CARRUBBA A., SARNO M., 2025 - Utilizing cactus pear pruning residuals as sustainable growing media for containerized basil (Ocimum basilicum L.). - PLOS ONE, 20(10): e0334018.
  10. AVASILOAIEI D.I., CALARA M., BREZEANU P.M., BĂLĂIȚĂ C., BRUMĂ I.S., BREZEANU C., 2025 - Optimizing tomato yield and quality in greenhouse cultivation through fertilization and soil management. - Agronomy, 15: 2045.
  11. BACCHETTA L., CANDITELLI M., PLATAMONE G., PROCACCI S., DI PALMA P. R., MACCIONI O., MONTEREALI M. R., ALISI C., FORNI C., 2024 - Use of cactus pear pruning waste to improve soil properties and to produce high-quality compost. - Organic Agri., 14: 263-275.
  12. BERKOVICH Y.A., KONOVALOVA I.O., SMOLYANINA S.O., EROKHIN A.N., AVERCHEVA O.V., BASSARSKAYA E.M., KOCHETOVA G.V., ZHIGALOVA T.V., YAKOVLEVA O.S., TARAKANOV I.G., 2017 - LED crop illumination inside space greenhouses. - REACH, 6: 11-24.
  13. BIYADA S., MERZOUKI M., DĖMČĖNKO T., VASILIAUSKIENĖ D., MARČIULAITIENĖ E., VASAREVIČIUS S., URBONAVIČIUS J., 2022 - The effect of feedstock concentration on the microbial community dynamics during textile waste composting. - Front. Ecol. Evol., 10: 813488.
  14. BRZOZOWSKI L., MAZOUREK M., 2018 - A sustainable agricultural future relies on the transition to organic agroecological pest management. - Sustainability, 10: 2023.
  15. BU X., JI H., MA W., MU C., XIAN T., ZHOU Z., WANG F., XUE J., 2022 - Effects of biochar as a peat-based substrate component on morphological, photosynthetic and biochemical characteristics of Rhododendron delavayi Franch. - Scientia Hortic., 302: 111148.
  16. CAMPOS P., SÁNCHEZ-MARTÍN Á.M., LUCAS M., SANTA-OLALLA A., ROSALES M.A., DE LA ROSA J.M., 2025 - Biochar and compost as sustainable alternatives to peat. - Agronomy, 15: 2455.
  17. CHEN S., LIU A., TANG F., HOU P., LU Y., YUAN P., 2025 - A review of environmental control strategies and models for modern agricultural greenhouses. - Sensors, 25(4): 1388.
  18. CHRYSARGYRIS A., SKALTSA H., KONSTANTOPOULOU M., 2022 - Medicinal and aromatic plants (MAPs): The connection between cultivation practices and biological properties. - Agronomy, 12: 3108.
  19. DEHOUCHE N., IDRES C., KACI M., ZEMBOUAI I., BRUZAUD S., 2020 - Effects of various surface treatments on Aloe vera fibers used as reinforcement in poly(3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyhexanoate) (PHBHHx) biocomposites. - Polymer Degradation Stability, 175: 109131.
  20. DHANKHAR N., KUMAR J., 2023 - Impact of increasing pesticides and fertilizers on human health: A review. - Proceedings Materials Today, pp. 1-5.
  21. DI PALMA P.R., GAZZOLA G., PROCACCI S., MACCIONI O., MONTEREALI M. R., TOLAINI V., CANDITELLI M., BACCHETTA L., 2025 - Composting a mixture of cactus pear pruning waste and spent coffee grounds: The chemical evaluation of organic fertilizer in response to basil quality and growth. - Horticulturae, 11(6): 640.
  22. EL EUCH S.K., HASSINE D., CAZAUX S., BOUZOUITA N., BOUAJILA J., 2019 - Salvia officinalis essential oil: Chemical analysis and evaluation of anti-enzymatic and antioxidant bioactivities. - South Afr. J. Bot., 120: 253-260.
  23. FARHADI N., BABAEI K., FARSARAEI S., MOGHADDAM M., PIRBALOUTI A.G., 2020 - Changes in essential oil compositions, total phenol, flavonoids and antioxidant capacity of Achillea millefolium at different growth stages. - Industrial Crops Products, 152: 112570.
  24. GIL-MARTÍNEZ M., MADEJÓN E., 2025 - Compost and vegetation cover drive soil fertility, microbial activity, and community in organic farming soils. - Plant Soil, 516: 229-321.
  25. GRUBER B.D., GIEHL R.F., FRIEDEL S., VON WIRÉN N., 2013 - Plasticity of the Arabidopsis root system under nutrient deficiencies. - Plant Physiol., 163(1): 161-179.
  26. HADAR Y., PAPADOPOULOU K.K., 2012 - Suppressive composts: Microbial ecology links between abiotic environments and healthy plants. - Ann. Rev. Phytopathol., 50: 133-153.
  27. HUSSAIN A.I., ANWAR F., CHATHA S.A., JABBAR A., MAHBOOB S., NIGAM P.S., 2010 - Rosmarinus officinalis essential oil: Anti-proliferative, antioxidant and antibacterial activities. - Brazilian J. Microbiol., 41(4): 1070-1078.
  28. JAMAL A., SAEED M.F., MIHOUB A., HOPKINS B.G., AHMAD I., NAEEM A., 2023 - Integrated use of phosphorus fertilizer and farmyard manure improves wheat productivity by improving soil quality and P availability in calcareous soil under subhumid conditions. - Front. Plant Sci., 14: 1034421.
  29. JARAMILLO I.E., COCCO C., KANG J.J., CHENG C.-L., PEREIRA E., 2025 - Turning waste into fertilizer: Aloe vera leaf shavings improve plant growth and support soil fertility in organic systems. - Soil Systems, 9: 113.
  30. LANGE D., 2002 - Medicinal and aromatic plants: Trade, production, and management of botanical resources. - Acta Horticulturae, 629: 177-197.
  31. LEPORINI M., BONESI M., LOIZZO M. R., PASSALACQUA N. G., TUNDIS R., 2020 - The essential oil of Salvia rosmarinus Spenn. from Italy as a source of health-promoting compounds: Chemical profile and antioxidant and cholinesterase inhibitory activity. - Plants, 9(6): 798.
  32. LING Q., HUANG W., JARVIS P., 2011 - Use of a SPAD-502 meter to measure leaf chlorophyll concentration in Arabidopsis thaliana. - Photosynthesis Res., 107(2): 209-214.
  33. LIONTAKIS A., TZOURAMANI I., 2016 - Economic sustainability of organic Aloe vera farming in Greece under risk and uncertainty. - Sustainability, 8(4): 338.
  34. LIU S., CUI S., ZHANG X., WANG Y., MI G., GAO Q., 2020 - Synergistic regulation of nitrogen and sulfur on redox balance of maize leaves and amino acids balance of grains. - Front. Plant Sci., 11: 576718.
  35. MALIEHE T.S., NQOTHENI M.I., SHANDU J.S., SELEPE T.N., MASOKO P., POOE O.J., 2023 - Chemical profile, antioxidant and antibacterial activities, mechanisms of action of the leaf extract of Aloe arborescens Mill. - Plants, 12(4): 869.
  36. MATHERI F., KAMBURA A.K., MWANGI M., ONGESO N., KARANJA E., ADAMTEY N., MWANGI E.K., MWANGI E., TANGA C., MUSYOKA M.W., 2023 - Composition, structure, and functional shifts of prokaryotic communities in response to co-composting of various nitrogenous green feedstocks. - BMC Microbiology, 23(1): 50.
  37. MIGUEL M.G., 2010 - Antioxidant and anti-inflammatory activities of essential oils: A short review. - Molecules, 15(12): 9252-9287.
  38. MINGYANG C., ZHIXIN D., XIAOYU L., JUNZE C., 2022 - Physiological and ecological characteristics and reproductive responses of Phragmites australis to dry-wet conditions in inland saline marshes of Northeast China. - PeerJ., 10: e14269.
  39. MONTOYA D., FERNÁNDEZ J.A., FRANCO J.A., DEL CARMEN MARTÍNEZ BALLESTA M., 2022 - Enriched-biochar application increases broccoli nutritional and phytochemical content without detrimental effect on yield. - J. Sci. Food Agric., 102(17): 7353-7362.
  40. MUSCOLO A., PAPALIA T., SETTINERI G., MALLAMACI C., JESKE-KACZANOWSKA A., 2018 - Are raw materials or composting conditions and time that most influence the maturity and quality of composts? Comparison of obtained composts on soil properties. - J. Cleaner Prod., 195: 93-101.
  41. NAGUIB A.E.-M.M., EL-BAZ F.K., SALAMA Z.A., HANAA H.A.E.B., ALI H.F., GAAFAR A.A., 2012 - Enhancement of phenolics, flavonoids and glucosinolates of broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. italica) as antioxidants in response to organic and bio-organic fertilizers. - J. Saudi Soc. Agric. Sci., 11(2): 135-142.
  42. OUELD LHAJ M., MOUSSADEK R., MOUHIR L., SANAD H., MANHOU K., IBEN HALIMA O., YACHOU H., ZOUAHRI A., MDARHRI ALAOUI M., 2025 - Application of compost as an organic amendment for enhancing soil quality and sweet basil (Ocimum basilicum L.) growth: Agronomic and ecotoxicological evaluation. - Agronomy, 15: 1045.
  43. PAN I.C., JIANG C.A., CHIOU W.Y., CHEN Y.C., 2025 - Improving sustainable vegetable production with biochar and chitosan xerogel combination under water and fertilizer stress. - Horticulturae, 11: 1448.
  44. PANE C., SPACCINI R., PICCOLO A., CELANO G., ZACCARDELLI M., 2019 - Disease suppressiveness of agricultural greenwaste composts as related to chemical and bio-based properties shaped by different on-farm composting methods. - Biol. Control, 137: 104026.
  45. PAPAFOTIOU M., MARTINI A.N., TASSOULA L., STYLIAS E.G., KALANTZIS A., DARIOTIS E., 2022 - Acclimatization of Mediterranean native sages (Salvia spp.) and interspecific hybrids in an urban green roof under regular and reduced irrigation. - Sustainability, 14: 4978.
  46. PATEL N., IEVIŅA B., KAŽMĒRE D., FEOFILOVS M., KAMENDERS A., ROMAGNOLI F., 2025 - Towards resilient peatlands: Integrating ecosystem-based strategies, policy frameworks, and management approaches for sustainable transformation. - Sustainability, 17: 3419.
  47. PERGOLA M., PERSIANI A., PASTORE V., PALESE A.M., D’ADAMO C., DE FALCO E., CELANO G., 2020 - Sustainability assessment of the green compost production chain from agricultural waste: A case study in Southern Italy. - Agronomy, 10: 230.
  48. PIRANI H., EBADI M., REZAEI A., 2020 - Effect of seaweed fertilizer foliar application on growth parameters, yield, and essential oil content and composition of hyssop (Hyssopus officinalis L.). - Iranian J. Med. Aromatic Plants Res., 36: 376-389.
  49. PRISA D., GOBBINO M., 2021 - Sustainable methods based on microbial biofertilizers and plant repellent extracts in the cultivation of Aloe vera. - World J. Environ. Biosci., 10(1): 27-32.
  50. PROCACCI S., BOJÓRQUEZ-QUINTAL E., PLATAMONE G., MACCIONI O., VECCHIO V.L., MORREALE V., ALISI C., BALDUCCHI R., BACCHETTA L., 2021 - Opuntia ficus-indica pruning waste recycling: Recovery and characterization of mucilage from cladodes. - Natural Resources, 12(3): 91-101.
  51. RADHA M.H., LAXMIPRIYA N.P., 2014 - Evaluation of biological properties and clinical effectiveness of Aloe vera: A systematic review. - J. Tradit. Complementary Medicine, 5(1): 21-26.
  52. RAPPOSELLI E., MELITO S., BARMINA G.G., FODDAI M., AZARA E., SCARPA G.M., 2015 - Relationship between soil and essential oil profiles in Salvia desoleana populations: Preliminary results. - Natural Product Commun., 10(9): 1934578X1501000932.
  53. RÄSÄNEN A., ALBRECHT E., ANNALA M., ARO L., LAINE A.M., MAANAVILJA L., MUSTAJOKI J., RONKANEN A-K., SILVAN N., TARVAINEN O., TOLVANEN A., 2023 - After-use of peat extraction sites: A systematic review of biodiversity, climate, hydrological and social impacts. - Sci. Total Environ., 882: 163583.
  54. READ D., GREGORY P., 1997 - Surface tension and viscosity of axenic maize and lupin root mucilages. - New Phytol., 137(4): 623-628.
  55. SALMAN M., INAMULLAH, JAMAL A., MIHOUB A., SAEED M.F., RADICETTI E., AHMAD I., NAEEM A., ULLAH J., PAMPANA S., 2023 - Composting sugarcane filter mud with different sources differently benefits sweet maize. - Agronomy, 13(3): 748.
  56. SARWARI A., ABDIEVA G.Z., HASSAND M.H., MOHAMMAD U., NIAZI P., 2024 - Role of microbial communities in compost and plant growth: Structure and function. - European J. Theor. Appl. Sci., 2(2): 23-37.
  57. SEMEREL J., JOHN N., DEHAEN W., FARDIM P., 2023 - Valorization of Aloe barbadensis Miller. (Aloe vera) processing waste. - J. Renewable Materials, 11(3): 1031-1061.
  58. SHAHINA Z., AL HOMSI R., PRICE J.D., WHITEWAY M., SULTANA T., DAHMS T.E., 2022 - Rosemary essential oil and its components 1,8-cineole and α-pinene induce ROS-dependent lethality and ROS-independent virulence inhibition in Candida albicans. - PLoS One, 17(11): e0277097.
  59. SORTINO G., GUCCIONE E., CASALES F.G., DE CHIARA M.L.V., PASSAFIUME R., GALLOTTA A., ALLEGRA A., 2024 - Application of Opuntia ficus-indica mucilage and Aloe gel-based edible coating to enhance postharvest quality and microbiological aspects of fresh figs (Ficus carica L.). - Horticulturae, 10: 482.
  60. TAWARAYA K., TURJAMAN M., EKAMAWANTI H.A., 2007 - Effect of arbuscular mycorrhizal colonization on nitrogen and phosphorus uptake and growth of Aloe vera L. - HortSci., 42(7): 1737.
  61. TONG Y., MA J., MIN X., TONG Y., 2025 - Effect of drought and salinity on water relations and photosynthetic responses of Tamarix elongata and Haloxylon ammodendron in Wutonggou Desert Tourist Area, Northwest China. - Diversity, 17: 235.
  62. VALIKI S.R.H., GHANBARI S., 2015 - Comparative examination of the effect of manure and chemical fertilizers on yield and yield components of rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis L.). - Inter. J. Agron. Agricul. Res., 6(1): 29-37.
  63. VANCE E.D., BROOKES P.C., JENKINSON D.S., 1987 - An extraction method for measuring soil microbial biomass C. - Soil Biol. Biochem., 19(6): 703-707.
  64. VELIU M., LÓPEZ-ROMANO H., PICCA G., PANETTIERI M., MORENO-JIMÉNEZ E., COURTIER-MURIAS D., JEAN-SORO L., GASPERI J., DE SOSA L.L., 2025 - Biochar-compost blends modulate trace element and nutrient dynamics in rooftop farming systems under Mediterranean conditions. - Ecotoxicol. Environ. Safety, 302: 118663.
  65. YUAN Z., CAO Q., ZHANG K., ATA-UL-KARIM S. T., TIAN Y., ZHU Y., CAO W., LIU X., 2016 - Optimal leaf positions for SPAD meter measurement in rice. - Front. Plant Sci., 7: 719.
  66. ZHANG G.Z., JIANG W.H., ZHU Y.H., SUN G.T., XU H., ZHU M.Q., 2025 - Effects of photosynthetic properties, soil environment and bioactive constituents of Eucommia ulmoides Oliver under two planting models. - BMC Plant Biology, 25(1): 826.
  67. ZHENG X., WANG Z., ZHU Y., WANG J., LIU B., 2020 - Effects of a microbial restoration substrate on plant growth and rhizosphere bacterial community in a continuous tomato cropping greenhouse. - Scientific Reports, 10(1): 13729.