No. 11 (2016): Emotions, Normativity, and Social Life
Session 3. Emotions, Language, and Hate Speech

Not All Slurs are Equal

Published January 4, 2017
Keywords
  • slurs,
  • derogatives,
  • variable offence
How to Cite
Popa-Wyatt, M. (2017). Not All Slurs are Equal. Phenomenology and Mind, (11), 150-156. https://doi.org/10.13128/Phe_Mi-20115

Abstract

Slurs are typically defined as conveying contempt based on group-membership. However, here I argue that they are not a unitary group. First, I describe two dimensions of variation among derogatives: how targets are identified, and how offensive the term is. This supports the typical definition of slurs as opposed to other derogatives. I then highlight problems with this definition, mainly caused by variable offence across slur words. In the process I discuss how major theories of slurs can account for variable offence, and conclude that contempt based on group-membership doesn’t cover all the data. I finish by noting that the most offensive slurs are those that target oppressed groups. I claim it is oppression that underpins most offence, and that beyond this offensive property, some slurs are actively used to oppress.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...