Just Accepted Manuscripts
Articles

The Dark side of simultaneous elections. The case of Sicily in 2022 Italian national elections

PDF Just Accepted
Supplementary Materials - Just Accepted
  • Danilo Di Mauro,
  • Marco La Bella
Danilo Di Mauro
University of Catania
Marco La Bella
University of Catania
Bio
DOI: https://doi.org/10.36253/qoe-15717

Published 2024-11-28

Keywords

  • Turnout,
  • Simultaneous Elections,
  • Invalid Vote

How to Cite

Di Mauro, D., & La Bella, M. (2024). The Dark side of simultaneous elections. The case of Sicily in 2022 Italian national elections. Italian Journal of Electoral Studies (IJES). https://doi.org/10.36253/qoe-15717

Copyright (c) 2024 Danilo Di Mauro, Marco La Bella

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Abstract

Instruments of “electoral engineering” such as compulsory voting, incentives and simultaneous multi-level voting, have become pretty common in contemporary democracies, especially in areas with low turnout rates. Simultaneous elections – i.e. the practice of establishing an election day when different governments (usually at local and national level, or including referendums) are elected – implies a reduction of costs for the institutions and increased empowerment for voters. However, these kinds of measures do not address the deep sentiments of disaffection for political institutions that often lie at the origin of non-voting. Moreover, simultaneous elections with different voting rules might confuse voters, thus increasing the number of invalid votes or no-choice. In order to examine the advantages and the threats of simultaneous elections, this study focuses on the recent case of the Italian general elections of 25th of September 2022, during which also the elections of the president and the regional assembly of Sicily were run simultaneously. This represents a regional context where atavistic disaffection and high volatility have marked the turnout rate of the last thirty years. By looking at the results of national elections within municipalities through a difference-in-difference strategy, we observe a slight increase in turnout rate in Sicilian municipalities. However, the number of both null and blank votes is significantly higher in Sicilian towns, suggesting a threatening effect of simultaneous voting.    

PDF Just Accepted
Supplementary Materials - Just Accepted

References

  1. Angelucci, D., Trastulli, F., & Tuorto, D. (2024). Cronaca di una morte annunciata. La partecipazione elettorale in Italia, 2022. In A. Chiaramonte & L. De Sio (Eds.), Un polo solo: Le elezioni politiche del 2022 (pp. 107-138). Il Mulino.
  2. Albertazzi, D., & Vampa, D. (2021). Populism and New Patterns of Political Competition in Western Europe. Abingdon and New York. Routledge.
  3. Aylott, N., & Bolin, N. (2023). A New Right: the Swedish Parliamentary Election of September 2022. West European Politics, 46(5), 1049-1062.
  4. Bartolini, S. (1986). La volatilità elettorale. Italian Political Science Review/Rivista Italiana di Scienza Politica, 16(3), 363-400.
  5. Bhatti, Y., Hansen, K. M. (2012). The effect of generation and age on turnout to the Eu-ropean Parliament – How turnout will continue to decline in the future. Electoral Studies, 31(2), 262–272.
  6. Blondel, J., Sinnott, R., Svensson, P. (1997). Representation and voter participation. European Journal of Political Research, 32(2), 243–272.
  7. Caciagli, M. (1988). Quante Italie? Persistenza e trasformazione delle culture politiche subnazionali. Polis, 3, 429-457.
  8. Carteny, G., & Puleo, F. (2022). Verso un M5S a trazione socialdemocratica?. Rivistailmulino.it. https://www.rivistailmulino.it/a/verso-un-m5s-a-trazione-socialdemocratica.
  9. Chiaramonte, A., & Emanuele, V. (2013). Volatile and tripolar: the new Italian party system. In L. De Sio, V. Emanuele, N. Maggini, & A. Paparo, (Eds.), Italian General Elections of 2013: A dangerous stalemate? (pp. 63-68). CISE.
  10. Chiaramonte, A., & D'Alimonte, R. (2018). The New Italian Electoral System and its Effects on Strategic Coordination and Disproportionality. Italian Political Science, 13(1), 8-18.
  11. Chiaramonte, A., & De Sio, L. (2024). Un polo solo. Le elezioni politiche del 2022. Bologna, il Mulino.
  12. Cerruto, M., & La Bella, M. (2022). Le elezioni regionali in Sicilia del 2022. Regional Studies and Local Development, 3, 1-12.
  13. Cerruto, M., & Raniolo, F. (2009). Dal partito dominante alla coalizione dominante: le elezioni regionali in Sicilia (1947-2008). Italian Journal of Electoral Studies (IJES), 61(1), 41-98.
  14. Cerruto, M., & La Bella, M. (2018). Le elezioni regionali in Sicilia del 5 novembre 2017. Italian Journal of Electoral Studies (IJES), 80(2), 29-82.
  15. Cerruto, M., & La Bella, M. (2024). Una transizione politica senza fine. Il sistema politico siciliano alla prova del voto. Istituzioni del Federalismo, 1, 165-205.
  16. Chen, T.H. (2011). Uncovering the micro-foundations of turnout and electoral systems. Electoral Studies, 30(2), 295–308.
  17. Cantoni, E., Gazzè, L., & Schafer, J. (2021). Turnout in concurrent elections: Evidence from two quasi-experiments in Italy. European Journal of Political Economy, 70, 102305.
  18. Cantoni, E., & Pons, V. (2021). Do interactions with candidates increase voter support and participation? Experimental evidence from Italy. Economics & Politics, 33(2), 379-402.
  19. Cavatorto, S., De Giorgi, E., & Piccolino, G. (2021). Next Generation EU nel governo parlamentare italiano. Rivista Italiana di Politiche Pubbliche (3), 377-403.
  20. Dahlberg, S., & Solevid, M. (2016). Does corruption suppress voter turnout? Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties, 26(4), 489-510.
  21. D’Amico, R. (1993). La “cultura elettorale” dei siciliani. In M. Morisi (Ed.), Far politica in Sicilia. Deferenza, consenso e protesta (pp. 211-257). Milano: Feltrinelli.
  22. Di Mauro, D. (2016). Economic Crisis and Electoral Participation in European Elections. An Assessment of the Relationship. Partecipazione e Conflitto, 9(1), 46-71.
  23. Durovic, A. (2023). Rising electoral fragmentation and abstention: the French elections of 2022. West European Politics, 46(3), 614-629.
  24. Feltrin, P. (1990). Le elezioni regionali: struttura e costanti delle scelte di voto. In M. Caciagli & A. Spreafico (Eds.), Vent'anni di elezioni in Italia. 1968-1987 (pp. 295-319). Padova: Liviana Editrice.
  25. Fieldhouse E., Tranmer, M., & Russell, A. (2007). Something about young people or some-thing about elections? Electoral participation of young people in Europe: Evidence from a multilevel analysis of the European Social Survey. European Journal of Political Research, 46(6): 797-822.
  26. Giovannini, A., Valbruzzi, M., & Vampa, D. (2023), The 2022 Italian general election: a political shock or the new normal? Italian Journal of Electoral Studies (IJES), 86(1), 3-11.
  27. Kostelka, F., & Blais, A. (2023). The generational and institutional sources of the global decline in voter turnout. World Politics, 73(4), 629-667.
  28. Lami, G., & Sahota, S. K. (2022). The Russian invasion of Ukraine: some readings from Italian newspapers (20 February-5 March 2022). Modern Italy, 27(3), 199-206.
  29. Lijphart, A. (1997). Unequal participation: Democracy's unresolved dilemma presidential address. American Political Science Review, 91(1), 1-14.
  30. Leininger, A., Rudolph, L., & Zittlau, S. (2018). How to increase turnout in low-salience elections: Quasi-experimental evidence on the effect of concurrent second-order elections on political participation. Political Science Research and Methods, 6(3), 509-526.
  31. Mbah, R. E., & Wasum, D. F. (2022). Russian-Ukraine 2022 War: A review of the economic impact of Russian-Ukraine crisis on the USA, UK, Canada, and Europe. Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal, 9(3), 144-153.
  32. Marini, S., & Piccolino, G. (2023). Right-wing victory in the 2022 Italian parliamentary election: territorial patterns and systemic implications. Italian Journal of Electoral Studies (IJES), 86(1), 29-50.
  33. Pasquino, P. (2023). I partiti e la formazione del governo. Quaderni Costituzionali, 43(4), 753-770.
  34. Reif, K., & Schmitt, H. (1980). Nine second‐order national elections–a conceptual framework for the analysis of European Election results. European Journal of Political Research, 8(1), 3-44.
  35. Sartori, G. (1976). Parties and party systems. Volume 1: A framework for analysis. Cambridge University Press.
  36. Schakel, A. H., & Jeffery, C. (2013). Are regional elections really ‘second-order’elections? Regional Studies, 47(3), 323-341.
  37. Schmitt, H., Segatti, P., & van der Ejik, C. (Eds.) (2021). Consequences of context: How the social, political, and economic environment affects voting. London, Lanham: ECPR Press.
  38. Simon, R. (2020). Two-bloc Logic, Polarisation and Coalition Government: He November 2019 General Election in Spain. South European Society and Politics, 25(3-4), 533-563.
  39. Vampa, D. (2023). Italy: Populism and business in a stagnant economy. In M. Feldmann & G. Morgan (Eds.), Business Elites and Populism: The Odd Couple? (pp. 118-137). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  40. Vassallo, S., & Verzichelli, L. (Eds.) (2023). II bipolarismo asimmetrico. L'Italia al voto dopo il decennio populista. Bologna. Il Mulino.