Vol. 15 No. 29 (2025): Situare il sapere: sfide epistemologiche e questioni di metodo tra nord e sud
Open Essays and Researches

Philanthropic foundations as field-builders: insights from two emblematic Italian cases

PDF
  • Paola Arrigoni
Paola Arrigoni
Università di Bologna, Italia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.36253/cambio-16706

Published 2025-07-21

Keywords

  • Philanthropy,
  • italian foundations,
  • field-building approach,
  • depoliticization/politicization frame,
  • philanthropic policymaking

How to Cite

Arrigoni, P. (2025). Philanthropic foundations as field-builders: insights from two emblematic Italian cases . Cambio. Rivista Sulle Trasformazioni Sociali, 15(29), 147–164. https://doi.org/10.36253/cambio-16706

Copyright (c) 2025 Paola Arrigoni

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Abstract

To date, the scholars who have studied Italian philanthropic foundations have mainly focused on their function as the funders of various kinds of initiatives or policies. Only rarely have they investigated the foundations’ input to policymaking processes, while virtually never examining foundations’ role as field builders, that is to say, as actors with the power to influence how fields are defined and delimited in the context of policymaking. Drawing on a large corpus of official documents and semi-structured interviews, the paper addresses this under-studied role of philanthropic foundations in relation to two Italian cases: the university policies of one of the country’s largest foundations of banking origin; the climate policies of the main climate networks to which Italian foundations belong. The foundations’ presumed field-building role is explored from both the organizational-relational and discursive perspectives. Next, the twin concepts of depoliticization/politicization frame discussion of the hypothesis that, in both cases studied, the foundations’ involvement in policymaking entails a discursive depoliticization of public action and a governmental and social politicization of their own actions. The data analysis appears to confirm the research hypotheses, raising questions surrounding the actual innovative reach of philanthropic foundations and the relationship they establish with public actors.

PDF

References

  1. Apajalahti E.L, Temmes A., Lempiälä T. (2018), Incumbent organisations shaping emerging technological fields: cases of solar photovoltaic and electric vehicle charging, in «Technology Analysis & Strategic Management», 30, 1, 44-57.
  2. Arrigoni P. (2024), Élite, filantropia e trasformazioni dello Stato. La Compagnia San Paolo di Torino, Bologna: il Mulino.
  3. Barbetta, G. (2008), Le fondazioni di origine bancaria: dalla nascita per caso all’esercizio della innovazione sociale, in Turati G., Piacenza M., Segre G. (cur.), Patrimoni e scopi. Per un’analisi economica delle fondazioni, Torino: Edizioni Fondazione Giovanni Agnelli.
  4. Bartley, T. (2007), How foundations shape social movements: The construction of an organizational field and the rise of forest certification, in «Social problems», 54, 3, 229–255.
  5. Betsill M., Enrici A., Le Cornu E., Gruby R. (2022), Philanthropic foundations as agents of environmental governance: a research agenda, in «Environmental Politics», 31, 4, 684-705.
  6. Burnham P. (2001), New Labour and the politics of depoliticization, in «British Journal of Politics and International Relations», 3, 2, 127-149.
  7. Burroni L., Ramella F., Trigilia C. (2017), Fondazioni e sviluppo locale, Roma: Donzelli.
  8. Coin F. (2011), L’organizzazione scientifica della ricerca umanistica, in «Archivio di studi urbani e regionali», 101,102, 175-181.
  9. Coin F. (2018), L’inadeguatezza del digital academic, in «Rivista trimestrale di scienza dell’amministrazione», 1, 1, 1-23.
  10. d’Albergo E., Moini G. (2019), Politica e azione pubblica nell’epoca della depoliticizzazione. Attori, pratiche e istituzioni, Roma: Sapienza Università Editrice.
  11. De Martin J. C. (2017), Università futura - tra democrazia e bit, Torino: Codice Edizioni.
  12. Depecker T., Déplaude M.O., Larchet N. (2018), La philanthropie comme investissement. Contribution à l’étude des stratégies de reproduction et de légitimation des élites économiques, in «Politix», 121, 9-27.
  13. Gabay G., Ilcan S. (2017), Leaving No-one Behind? The Politics of Destination in the 2030 Sustainable Development Goals, in «Globalizations», 14 (3), 337-242.
  14. Lefèvre S., Monier A. (2021), Philanthropes en démocratie, Paris: PUF.
  15. Lounsbury M., Ventresca M., Hirsch P.M. (2003), Social movements, field frames and industry emergence, in «Socio-Economic Review», 1, 1, 71-104.
  16. Madénian H. Van Neste S. L. (2023), Philanthropic foundations as urban climate policy entrepreneurs, in «Journal of Urban Affairs», 47, 1, 159-176.
  17. Mazzucato M., Collington R. (2023), Il grande imbroglio. Come le società di consulenza indeboliscono le imprese, infantilizzano i governi e distorcono l’economia, Bari: Laterza.
  18. McMichael P. (2009), Contesting Development: Critical Struggles for Social Change, London: Routledge.
  19. Mills C.W. (1959), The Sociological Imagination, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  20. Mills C. W. (1940), Situated Actions and Vocabularies of Motive, in «American Sociological Review», 5, 6, 904-913.
  21. Mitchell K., Sparke M. (2016), The New Washington Consensus: Millennial Philanthropy and the Making of Global Market Subjects, in «Antipode», 48, 724-749.
  22. Mitsushima N. (2017), Aménager, subvertir et contester l’ordre électoral: Philanthropie et politique sous la Restauration (1819-1830), in «Genèses», 109, 32-56.
  23. Monier A. (2023), The Mobilization of the Philanthropic Sector for the Climate: A New Engagement?, in Kassiola J., Luke T.W. (eds.), The Palgrave Handbook of Environmental Politics and Theory. Environmental Politics and Theory, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
  24. Morena E. (2016), The price of climate action, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
  25. Mosley J.E, Galaskiewicz, J. (2015), The relationship between philanthropic foundation funding and state-level policy in the era of welfare reform, in «Nonprofit and Voluntary. Sector Quarterly», 44, 6, 1225–1254.
  26. Pierri P. (2019), Filantropia. Attori, caratteristiche e prospettive in Italia, Milano: AIPB.
  27. Ravazzi S. (2016), Philanthropic foundations and local policy-making in the austerity era: Does urban governance matter?, in «Lex Localis»,14, 4, 917-935.
  28. Reckhow S. (2016), More than Patrons: How Foundations Fuel Policy Change and Backlash, in «Political Science & Politics», 49, 3, 449-454.
  29. Skocpol T. (2016), Why Political Scientists Should Study Organized Philanthropy, in «Political Science and Politics», 49, 3, 433-436.
  30. Suarez D.S. (2012), Grant making as advocacy. The emergence of social justice Philanthropy, in «Nonprofit Management & Leadership», 22, 3, 259-280.
  31. Weber H. (2017), Politics of ‘Leaving No One Behind’: Contesting the 2030 Sustainable Development Goals Agenda, in «Globalizations», 14, 3, 1-16.