Vol. 84 (2024)
Original Articles - Urban, Land, Environmental Appraisal and Economics

From fair market value to judicial market value of real estate

PDF
  • Silvio Menghini,
  • Veronica Alampi Sottini,
  • Roberto Fratini
Silvio Menghini
Department of Agriculture, Food, Environment and Forestry (DAGRI), University of Florence
Veronica Alampi Sottini
Department of Agriculture, Food, Environment and Forestry (DAGRI), University of Florence
Roberto Fratini
Department of Agriculture, Food, Environment and Forestry (DAGRI), University of Florence
DOI: https://doi.org/10.36253/aestim-15228

Published 2024-08-04

Keywords

  • Auction market,
  • appraisal,
  • Execution sale

Copyright (c) 2024 Silvio Menghini, Veronica Alampi Sottini, Roberto Fratini

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Crossref
Scopus
Google Scholar
Europe PMC

Abstract

ABSTRACT

The paper proposes a brief analysis of the main elements that, on a theoretical, normative and situational basis, affect the value of properties placed as collateral for loans, with particular reference to the value they assume in the event that they are affected by an enforced procedure instead of being subject to normal sale, in free market conditions.

Starting from the classic analytical estimate of the fair market value of a real estate asset in free market conditions, the paper will quantify the value that the asset should have when the appraiser has to indicate the value from which to start the judicial auction. Considering the regulatory mechanisms in place in Italy, the paper will put in evidence how a value calculated for an execution sale of a property occurring in a foreclosure process is considerably far from its fair market value and even more from its final judicial value, considered as the amount that will be recovered at the end of the sale of the property by judicial auction.

For both debtors and creditors, the significant differences between fair market, execution and judicial values become an increasingly topical issue in the face of the growing number of default and distress of loans.

PDF

References

  1. Astasy (2020). Report - Aste 2019. Anno Giudiziale 2019. Astasy. Available at: www.astasypoint.it/report-aste/ (accessed 2 May 2023).
  2. Associazione Bancaria Italiana - ABI (2019). Linee guida per la valutazione degli immobili in garanzia delle esposizioni creditizie. Available at: www.abi.it/mercati/crediti/valutazioni-immobiliari/linee-guida-valutazioni-immobiliari/ (accessed 2 May 2023).
  3. Amoruso, P., Mariani, M., d’Amato, M., & Didonato, R. (2020). Italian auction market: features of discounted forced sale price. Real Estate Management and Valuation, 28(3), 12–23. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/remav-2020-0020
  4. Bambagioni, G. (2022). Le valutazioni estimative nel contesto internazionale e Codice delle Valutazioni Immobiliari. Intervento XLVIII Incontro di Studi del CeSET, Firenze, 1-2 dicembre 2022.
  5. Di Liddo, F., Tajani, F., Amoruso, P., Ranieri, R., & Anelli, D. (2022) The assessment of the forced sale value in the Italian residential market. Aestimum, 80, 15–32. DOI: https://doi.org/10.36253/aestim-12953
  6. European Banking Authority - EBA (2020). Final Report - Guidelines on loan origination and monitoring. EBA/GL/2020/06, 29 May 2020. Available at: https://www.eba.europa.eu/legacy/regulation-and-policy/regulatory-activities/credit-risk/guidelines-loan-origination-and (accessed 10 June 2023).
  7. European Banking Authority - EBA (2022). Final Report - Final draft implementing technical standards on prudential disclosures on ESG risks in accordance with Article 449a CRR. EBA/IST/2022/01, 24 January 2022. Available at: https://www.eba.europa.eu/publications-and-media/press-releases/eba-publishes-binding-standards-pillar-3-disclosures-esg (accessed 2 May 2023).
  8. Federazione Autonoma Bancari Italiani (2023). Le rate non pagate dalle famiglie italiane valgono 15 miliardi. Analisi FABI, 8 luglio 2023. Available at: https://www.fabi.it/2023/07/08/le-rate-non-pagate-dalle-famiglie-italiane-valgono-15-miliardi-i-dati-regione-per-regione/ (accessed 3 August 2023).
  9. Fernandez, E. (2005). Fair valuation in real estate. In Real estate indicators and financial stability, Proceedings of a joint conference organised by the BIS and the IMF in Washington DC, October 27–28, 2003. BIS Papers, No 21, pp 340–351.
  10. Forte, C. (1968). Elementi di estimo urbano. Milano, ETAS Kompass.
  11. French, N. (2020). Pricing to Market. An investigation into the use of Comparable Evidence in Property Valuation. TEGoVa – The European Group of Valuers Association.
  12. Gaca, R. (2019). Price as a measure of market value on the real estate market. Real Estate Management and Valuation, 26(4), 68–77. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/remav-2018-0037
  13. Gallerani, V., Viaggi, D., & Zanni, G. (2011). Manuale di Estimo. Bologna, McGraw-Hill.
  14. Ieppariello, M. (2015). Il valore cauzionale nelle valutazioni degli immobili per la concessione del credito. Io Roma Quaderno n.2/2015, 81–87.
  15. International Valuation Standards Committee - IVSC (2007). International Valuations Standards (IVS) – 8th edition. London, International Valuation Standards Council.
  16. Locurcio, M., Tajani, F., Morano, P., & Anelli, D. (2021). A multi-criteria decision analysis for the assessment of the real estate credit risks. In Morano, P., Oppio, A., Rosato, P., Sdino, L., & Tajani, F. (Eds.). Appraisal and Valuation. Green Energy and Technology. Cham, Springer. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-49579-4_22
  17. Medici, G. (1977). Principi di Estimo. Milano, Calderini Editore.
  18. Michieli, I., & Michieli, M. (2011). Trattato di Estimo. Bologna, Edagricole-Gruppo24ore.
  19. Ministero della Giustizia (2022). Portale delle Vendite Pubbliche. Available at: https://venditepubbliche.giustizia.it/pvp/it/homepage.page (accessed 3 August 2023).
  20. Moncelli, M. (2021). Una proposta per definire il valore giudiziale di un immobile pignorato. L’Ufficio Tecnico, 10, 164–171.
  21. Morano, P., Rosato, P., Tajani, F., Manganelli, B., & Di Liddo, F. (2019). Contextualized property market models vs. generalized mass appraisals: an innovative approach. Sustainability, 11(18), 4896. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su11184896
  22. Osservatorio del Mercato Immobiliare - OMI (2022). Rapporto mutui ipotecari 2022. Pubblicazioni OMI.
  23. Penningon-Cross, A. (2006). The value of foreclosed property, Journal of Real Estate Research, 28(2), 193–214. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10835547.2006.12091177
  24. Pereira Grey, P. J. (2021). Independent Review of Real Estate Investment Valuations. RICS.
  25. Polelli, M. (1997). Trattato di Estimo. Milano, Maggioli Editore.
  26. REVIVA (2022). Scenario aste immobiliari. Available at: scenarioaste.it (accessed 3 August 2023).
  27. Spada, M. L. (2019). Recupero giudiziale dei crediti e crescita economica. In Costantino, L., Ingravallo, I., & Martino, P. (Eds.). Pace e sviluppo nell’epoca moderna. Il modello costaricense. Quaderni del Dipartimento Ionico, n.12/2019, pp. 155-171. Edizioni Dipartimento Jonico in Sistemi giuridici ed economici del Mediterraneo: società, ambiente, culture, Università degli Studi di Bari Aldo Moro.
  28. Susilawati, C., & Lin, V. (2006). Case analysis of auction market in Brisbane housing system. In Proceedings of the 12th Pacific Rim Real Estate Society Conference 2006 (pp. 1-17). Pacific Rim Real Estate Society (PRRES).
  29. Tajani, F., Morano, P., Locurcio, M., & Amoruso, P. (2021). A logical operating model for the assessment of the forced sale value in the judicial procedures. Valori e Valutazioni, 29, 23–39. DOI: https://doi.org/10.48264/VVSIEV-20212904

Most read articles by the same author(s)